Passage through India – Barefoot in Turbans

“A poor, hungry person knows no religion; to him, the person who offers him food is the real God.”― Raj Kiran Atagaraha

Our visit began at the site of what is called the Amritsar massacre.

The more correctly called Jallianwala Bagh massacre took place on 13th April 1919. After several days of civil disturbance a large, mainly peaceful crowd had gathered during a public holiday to protest in support of Indian independence.  In response Brigadier General, Reginald Dyer, surrounded the people and after blocking the exit with his troops either lost self control or in a lust for blood  ordered them to shoot at the crowd, continuing to fire even as the protesters tried to flee. The troops kept on firing until their ammunition was exhausted.  He boasted later that not a single bullet was wasted.

Estimates of those killed vary from 400 to 1,500.  The story is told as an act of British Army violence and an example of imperial tyranny but the British Army as an organisation was not directly involved in the massacre, the British Indian Army was a separate organisation and this was a regiment of Gurkha and Sikh infantry.  It is said that Dyer selected troops for the operation who were especially loyal to the British in India.  There was a prevailing fear of insurrection and civil violence.  There is always a flip-side to a story.  Just saying.

It is a dark stain on British imperial rule for sure and I am neither wishing to be controversial or to be an apologist but it is that time and forgiveness thing again that I spoke about in an earlier post.  Going back a few days to our time in  Delhi tour guide Rahi told the story of a Mongol invasion and massacre and it was told as though it was just a part of Indian history without passion or emotion.  Something that just happened.

In 1241 an invading Mongol army advanced and the ancient city of Lahore (now Pakistan) was invaded by an army of thirty-thousand blood-thirsty warriors from the north. The Mongols defeated the local army, massacred the entire population, cut off their heads and stuck them on poles to warn others not to stand in their way and the city was completely destroyed.   Rather like modern day Gaza.  Rather like the destruction of Warsaw in 1944.  And many more.  I have said this before that if there is one lesson from history it is that we learn nothing and history sadly and inevitably repeats itself. 

The massacre at Lahore is not told as a dreadful act of brutality in the same way as the Amritsar massacre.  Time dulls the senses, centuries pass, the tide washes the sands and history is whitewashed.  There is a lot of forgetting and forgiving over a thousand years.  Rather like the Norman Conquest in England.  Eventually we forget.

For the sake of balance at the siege of Cawnpore in 1857 over four hundred (estimate) British men, women and children were murdered at what is remembered as the Bibighar massacre which seems to have been an especially brutal affair.  No one mentions that of course.

We moved on now to the main event – a visit to the Golden Temple of Amritsar. For this visit we had to remove our shoes and socks and wear a bright orange turban.  It didn’t need to be orange I guess but the trader outside was selling orange.  I would have preferred blue for Leicester City but had to settle, like everyone else for Luton Town orange,

If almost everyone is aware of the Taj Mahal then they will know about the Golden Temple as well.  Not as grand, not as architecturally stunning but almost equally important.  I liked it immediately and there was a difference; Taj Mahal is a tourist attraction, Golden Temple is a religious site and it was possible to connect with that immediately.  To absorb it, to feel it, another impact site but for a different reason.  Spiritual, uplifting, calm, pure and I am fairly certain that all in the group responded immediately.

A serene lake, a line of pilgrims ignoring the rabble  of tourists and a floating golden temple like a golden galleon on the high seas.  There is something very special about this place for certain, shoeless people shuffle in silence around the lake, hundreds wait patiently in line to enter the temple and view the holy scriptures.  We didn’t have two hours to wait in line so we skipped that and went to the kitchens instead.

The kitchens and the dining hall were really something special.  Here the temple feeds one hundred thousand people a day, twenty four hours a day and it is all for free, anyone can turn up pick up a plate and enjoy a hearty meal.  This is the very essence of Sikhism.

I was inspired by this, I thought that maybe when I got home I would do something based on the Sikh lesson.  I am not going to grow a beard and wear a turban or have people round to my house for food everyday but maybe something a little less dramatic. Sadly I haven’t got around to it yet but it remains on my agenda.

I enjoyed this day above all others.  Nothing eclipses the Talj Mahal of course but  the Golden Temple was something special, mystical, spiritual, emotional and whilst the Taj Mahal remains in the memory the Golden Temple remains in the soul.  I will never forget it.  If time had allowed then I could happily have walked around that lake for a second time.

At the end of the day in Amritsar we said goodbye to our guide for the day Jaswinder Singh and I was sorry to see him go.  He had given us an informative and entertaining day.

I liked him so much that I have included his picture in the post twice.

On Christmas Day 2021  Jaswant Singh Chail entered the grounds of Windsor Castle, where Queen Elizabeth II was living, intending to assassinate her with a crossbow. He posted online “This is revenge for those who have died in the 1919 Jallianwala Bagh massacre”. He was arrested before entering the castle, and in February 2023, admitted three counts of treason, the last person to be charged and convicted of treason in the UK.

26 responses to “Passage through India – Barefoot in Turbans

  1. A very different and quite moving report this time Andrew

    Like

  2. An interesting day. Dyer sounds like an all round bad guy though. Have you read Anita Anand’s The Patient Assassin?

    Like

  3. Interesting and informative as always

    Like

  4. There are no partial or impartial mindset statements in any killings.
    A killing is a killing and an unwanted and avoidable one!
    The judgement mindset always dominates and depends on which side of the fence one belongs.
    It’s a sad state of affairs with human beings.
    Being neutral has zero value in any contributions
    Apologies for my rant.

    Like

  5. Murders and massacres aside, my first night in India in 1973 was spent at the Golden Temple – when you were allowed to sleep out in the open beside that lake. I think nowadays they have dormitories. It made quite an impression. As did the city the following day…

    Like

  6. Did you try Amritsar street food … especially marinated fried fish

    Like

  7. I never forget about the Norman Conquest. It is the enduring root of most of our present evils.

    Like

  8. As always, Andrew, interesting history and photos. Definitely sounds like a place to visit.

    Like

  9. Unusual to have you affected in this way, Andrew. It must be a very special place.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. One of my favourite posts from you, Andrew. Your classic style of historical education, with illustrations via photos, and your always direct commentary on your own experience. This time I am touched by how the site impacted you and glad to know you will carry this bit of India back home with you, to be used in a way you have yet to decide. The level of impact of this place on you – even though you did not have time to see it all – makes me especially eager to visit one day.

    Like

  11. Yes, The Golden temple is special. We stayed from the hotel not far from it and went there every day that we stayed there.

    Walking with Nanak by Haroon Khalid is a very good book.

    Like

  12. It sounds like a remarkable place and you reported on your visit very well. Thanks.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.